My puppy loves Himalayan chews and we enjoy these. They last a long time and they keep him busy and that makes me happy when I have to get some work done or some rest and know he’s having a good time chewing away. Make sure to take it away when it becomes a choking hazard, you can soak and microwave to turn it into a cheese puff. Much safer than the choking hazard at the end of it, and don’t have to toss the hazardous part. Just turn it into a new treat!